Pilates Styles - What's the Difference?
|
SO MANY STUDIOS CLAIM THEIR VERSION OF TEACHING
PILATES IS THE BEST STYLE OF THE PILATES METHOD. HAVE YOU HEARD THE CONTOVERSY
OR
ARE YOU BLISSFULLY
UNAWARE?
IS THERE A “RIGHT OR WRONG” KIND OF PILATES?
Joseph H. Pilates devised a body conditioning
system and technique, which contained an exact number of exercises, done in
specific
order with an
exact number of repetitions. He published this in a book in 1945, Return
To Life Through Contrology. After a number of years some of his students
went on to open and teach in studios of their own. Two of the most famous students
who went on to teach The Method are Romana Kryzanowska and Ron Fletcher. After
Joseph’s death, his wife Clara continued running the studio. In 1970,
Romana Kryzanowska took over and the studio became known as the “Pilates
Studio.” Both Romana and her daughter currently train people today and
their single most important mission in life is to preserve the original teachings
of Joseph H. Pilates.
Mary
Pilates

|
|
Mary Pilates is
the only living Pilates that ever
taught in the New York Studio and she is dedicated to preserving the
original techniques and legacy of her Uncle Joseph. Mary Pilates was
an instructor at the original Pilates studio when Romana Kryzanowska was a
pupil of her uncle
Joseph. Mary's father was Fred
Pilates,
the brother of Joseph and he designed and manufactured most of the original
Pilates equipment found in the New York Studio. Mary's father Fred also had
a Pilates studio in St. Louis Missouri in the mid 1900's. Mary grew up doing
Pilates, teaching Pilates and was also involved in the manufacture and design
of much of the original Pilates equipment. She has trained and certified an
elite few instructors in Original Pilates®,
the exact methodology taught to her by her Uncle Joseph H. Pilates and the
techniques she used while teaching
Pilates in the original Pilates studio. Additionally, she has certified a few
special studios and instructors in Original Pilates®,
including Fran Perel and Parkland Pilates.
Classic-Style Pilates (East Coast Pilates) is
a general
term to describe
the Pilates Method as was taught and practiced by Joseph H. Pilates himself
(or at least as close as possible to the original “Method”).
There is some disagreement as to which of the myriad branches of the original
Pilates method are the most “Classic,” but there is several
which have clearly remained as true as possible to the method as Joseph
himself had
taught it. The following are all valid providers of Classic Pilates instruction,
offering their own training and certifications:
West Coast Pilates. In
1971 Ron Fletcher opened a studio in Los Angeles and continues
to train people today. He
slightly adapted Joseph Pilates teachings. “I made adaptations
to the classical pieces of Joe’s equipment work, variations
on themes, so that this material could be presented on the floor
effectively, and I sought to create a piece of movement rather
than just a series of exercises.” (Ron Fletcher) Fletcher’s
work has evolved into several innovative trademarked programs
including Fletcher Percussive Breathing® and Fletcher Towelwork®.

Romana Kryzanowska hand-signed
a photo to Fran Perel at a workshop.
|
Contemporary Pilates is the next generation of
Pilates. Romana Kryzanowska trained Moira Stott-Merrithew in Classical
Pilates. Ironically, she went on to develop Stott Pilates®,
a contemporary adaptation of Joe’s work. Just as the world
has evolved in the past 50 years to having cell phones and sunscreens
up to number
50, so has Pilates, according to this school of thought. Stott
Pilates® re-arranged the order of the exercises, has variations
in breathing and movement. Most significantly, it is done with
a neutral pelvis and spine, acknowledging all the natural curves
of the spine. Stott Pilates® has adapted the original teachings
of Joseph Pilates by using modern-day science and knowledge.
Sean Gallagher in 1996 acquired the trademark
registrations for the Pilates service mark and Pilates Studio and
filed a copyright infringement lawsuit to limit the use of the
word “Pilates” to only those trained and certified
by Gallagher.
In October of 2000 there was a legal decision
in Manhattan Federal District Court that effectively cancelled
the Pilates trademark. This decision, while having the effect of
allowing certain longstanding Pilates centers and equipment manufacturers
to use the Pilates name without paying dues to any organization,
also opened up the possibility of anyone becoming a “certified” Pilates
instructor. There are now websites where prospective teachers can
purchase a “Pilates Certification” for $39.95!
As a result, potential Pilates clients must become
aware of the distinction between highly trained instructors in
the method approved by Joseph H. Pilates and those who have obtained
their certifications in a less rigorous means. All of the above-mentioned
offer their own certifications and all are valid methods.
If you are considering Pilates instruction, and
would like to be sure that you will be receiving the best training
possible, ask the Pilates instructor how they were certified, or
by whom, and how many hours of instruction/apprenticeship they
received. If they are certified by one of the schools listed above,
then you can be sure they have received an adequate amount of training.
Naturally this is important, from a safety standpoint, but it does
not account for the wide range of expertise, which is gained through
experience and natural talent.